Car News Articles 
 Alternative Fuel Vehicles (222)
  BioFuels (9)
  Electric Cars (61)
  Fuel Cells (7)
  Hybrid Cars (48)
 Automotive Articles
 Car Buying Tips
 Car Insurance Articles
 Car Maintenance
 Car News
 Car Racing
 Car Repair
 Car Safety
 Driving Economically
 Environmental Issues
 Exterior Car Care
 Garage Know How
 How Car Stuff Works
 Motorcycle Articles
 Road Trips
 Traveling with Kids
 Younger - Older Drivers
 Amsoil Synthetic Oil
 Article Archives

Alternative Fuel Vehicles

Which is Greener: The Prius or the Hummer?

Dear EarthTalk: I read that hybrid cars are actually less green-friendly than even Hummers, because they have two motors and very environmentally damaging batteries. Is this true?
-- Renee Sweany, Indianapolis, IN

The claim you read about was from “Dust to Dust: The Energy Cost of New Vehicles from Concept to Disposal,” a controversial study by researcher Art Spinella of Oregon-based CNW Marketing. It ranks more than 300 vehicles for their energy use over their entire lifecycles—from raw materials extraction and manufacturing, to driving and burning fuel, to the recycling and disposal of parts. What surprised even Spinella was how the Toyota Prius, the world’s most successful gasoline-electric hybrid car, stacked up against General Motors’ behemoth Hummer, the modern poster child for unsustainable transportation.

“The Hummer over the lifetime of the vehicle ends up being less of a drain of energy on society in general than does the Prius,” wrote Spinella in his report. A key-determining factor was the hybrid battery’s use of nickel extracted from a Sudbury, Ontario mine that has emitted so much sulfur dioxide that acid rain has turned a once healthy nearby forest into a bleak landscape. That mine, however, which supplies nickel for many industrial purposes and not just hybrid batteries, has cut pollution 90 percent since the 1970s.

Another common criticism of hybrids is that their batteries will be a pollution threat once they land in the junkyard. But hybrid advocates insist that the nickel-metal hydride batteries found in the Toyota Prius, Honda Insight and other hybrids contain far fewer pollutants than the lead-acid varieties used in traditional cars. And initial worries that hybrid batteries would need replacement every few years have not borne out; Toyota says the batteries should go for 150,000 miles, which they predict to be the car’s life expectancy.

Spinella pegs the life of the typical Prius bought new today at only 100,000 miles, and contrasts that against a predicted 300,000 for Hummers—meaning that, though Hummers burn more gas and emit more pollutants, they will last much longer. Additionally, Spinella factors in the added production costs of including two separate engines in the Prius—one that runs on gas and the other on electricity.

Most environmentalists challenge Spinella’s conclusions. Jim Kliesch, research analyst with the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE), which publishes a yearly rating of the “Greenest and Meanest” cars, says the CNW study contradicts many other studies, including those conducted by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Carnegie Mellon, Argonne National Labs, the Union of Concerned Scientists and others that place the green-friendliness of the Prius and other hybrids head and shoulders above many other vehicles and certainly the Hummer.

Spinella is “way off the mark,” says Kliesch, and scolds CNW for not having “Dust to Dust” peer-reviewed for accuracy. “If you do some back-of-the-envelope calculations on their claims,” he says, “you’ll find that it takes about $286,500 in energy to produce and assemble a Prius, [which is] absurd.”

Toyota itself also disputes CNW’s findings. In a short rebuttal published in the Washington Post, Toyota vice-president Irv Miller said that the increased energy requirement to build a hybrid with two engines under the hood “is overwhelmingly made up for in the driving stage.”

CONTACTS: “Dust to Dust,”; ACEEE,

GOT AN ENVIRONMENTAL QUESTION? Send it to: EarthTalk, c/o E/The Environmental Magazine, P.O. Box 5098, Westport, CT 06881; submit it at:, or e-mail: Read past columns at:

Related Articles:
Tesla Cars Introduces The Model X All Electric SUV
Amp Electric Jeep Grand Cherokee
Progressive Automotive X Prize
Toyota Goes Electric
The Wind Explorer - A Wind Powered Car
All Charged Up Over Electric Cars
The Rinspeed BamBoo The EV Goes To The Beach
Is there still a future for hydrogen-fueled fuel cell cars?
Nissan Electric Car The Nissan Leaf
Veritas RS III Roadster Hybrid
Porsche 918 Spyder Hybrid The Fastest Hybrid Plug-in
The SUNY Solar Car Model Racing Team's Sunhawk
Toyota Electric Cars - John Elfreth's EV
Twizy, Renault's Electric Microcar
The CODA Sedan - A Step Forward

make image
model image
zip code

Stay Updated!

Alternative Fuel Vehicles
Related Articles
Are Today's Battery Electric And
The Volkswagen XL1 Plug-in Hybrid
E15 Fuel: More Harm Than
Toyota FT-Bh Concept
Smart For-Us Pickup Truck
Tesla Cars Introduces The Model
Amp Electric Jeep Grand Cherokee
Progressive Automotive X Prize
Toyota Goes Electric
The Wind Explorer - A
All Charged Up Over Electric
The Rinspeed BamBoo The EV
Is there still a future
Nissan Electric Car The Nissan
Veritas RS III Roadster Hybrid
Porsche 918 Spyder Hybrid The
The SUNY Solar Car Model
Toyota Electric Cars - John
Twizy, Renault's Electric Microcar
The CODA Sedan - A

Feed Button

Car Insurance Info | Newsletter | Car Classifieds | Online Car Rentals
Auto Pictures | Link To

Complete List of Article RSS News Feeds

Copyright © 1999 - . CarJunky® All Rights Reserved.